Read Our Clients Reviews

Join VIP Savings Club

Rapid Repair Team

News & Media

Voted #1 People's Choice Award

Is it Worth Repairing or Replacing My Air Conditioner? An Honest Look at Both Options

If your air conditioner is on the fritz and you’re wondering whether it’s worth repairing or replacing, you’re not alone. Many homeowners face this dilemma every summer, when scorching temperatures make a working AC unit essential. Making the right decision when it comes to repair or replace air conditioner - can save you money in the long run—and ensure that your home stays cool and comfortable all season long. In this article, we'll explore both options to help you decide if it's time to repair or replace your air conditioner.

Why It’s Important For Homeowners To Make The Right Decision About AC Repair

As temperatures rise and the summer months approach, it's essential to make sure your air conditioner is in good working order.

But how do you know if you need to repair or replace it?

Making the wrong decision can be costly in terms of your energy bills and overall comfort.

That's why it's important to better understand both options' pros and cons. Let's look at both repair and replacement more closely so you can make an informed decision.

Benefits of repairing an existing AC unit, including cost savings

Repairing an existing AC unit can be cost-effective, as it may help avoid the expense of purchasing a brand new unit.

Additionally, repairing any minor issues can help keep your existing system running efficiently and may even extend its life expectancy.

Depending on the age and model of your current unit, repair costs are generally much lower than those associated with replacing the entire system.

However, it’s important to remember that certain problems—such as a damaged compressor—can be too costly to repair or may require extensive work that may not be worth the effort. In these cases, replacing your air conditioner is usually the best option.

A new air conditioner can help reduce energy bills and improve comfort

Replacing an old or inefficient air conditioner can be a wise decision for homeowners who want to reduce their energy bills and improve the comfort of your home.

The newer models operate at lower temperatures, meaning they use less energy to cool your home.

This can result in significantly lower energy bills throughout the summer months.

Additionally, many new models come with advanced features that offer improved comfort, such as variable fan speeds and humidity control settings.

Installing a new air conditioner can also make your home quieter since newer units are designed to be much quieter than older models.

Contact Dutch for schedule your AC repair and installation services - 573-315-3744

How to Diagnose Whether You Need to Repair or Replace Your Air Conditioner

5 Signs it's time to REPLACE Your Central AC

  1. If your air conditioner unit is 15+ years old
  2. It's making new noises
  3. Your energy bills are higher than you'd like them to be
  4. You're remodeling your home
  5. Your repair costs are adding up

and experiencing some issues, it may be worth considering replacement rather than repair.

Some signs that you should consider repairing your current AC unit include minor problems like decreased airflow or strange noises.

As well as more obvious signs such as leaks and a lack of cooling power.

5 Signs It's Time to REPAIR Your Central AC

  1. The thermostat appears functional, and the air is being emitted from the vents - regrettably, the air does not possess the necessary chill. Average repair cost in the industry:  $150-$300 plus diagnostic charge.
  2. Insufficient refrigerant can cause your AC to run longer and struggle to reach the desired temperature. Average repair cost in the industry:  $150/pound for R22, $70/pound for 410 plus diagnostic charge.
  3. Your condensate drain line is clogged. Average repair cost in the industry:  $150 plus diagnostic charge.
  4. You have an older and failing blower motor - you can usually tell this by an electrical burning smell or hearing a rotating banging and grinding sound. Average repair cost in the industry:  $800-900 plus diagnostic charge.
  5. Bad compressor or condenser fan motor - notice a tripped breaker or hear screeching or finding. Average repair cost in the industry for compressor:  $1200-1500 plus service charge. Average repair cost in the industry for condenser fan motor:  $700-900 plus service charge.

If you notice any of these signs, you'll want to call a professional HVAC technician to assess the issue. They can diagnose the problem and provide an estimate for repairs.

It's important to note that if the repair costs are close to the cost of purchasing a new unit, replacing it may be more economical in the long run than repairing it.

Learn more here about air conditioning services by Dutch!

Repair or replace air conditioner cost?

When deciding whether it is worth repairing or replacing an air conditioner, cost is a major factor to consider. Depending on the age and model of the unit, repair costs can range from just a few hundred dollars for minor problems up to several thousand dollars for more major repairs such as replacing the compressor.

Generally speaking, if the repair costs are more than half the cost of a new system, it might be best to invest in a replacement.

In addition, keep in mind that higher efficiency ratings generally mean lower energy bills over time—so even though you will be spending more money upfront for a new system, you may save money in the long run.

Additionally, when installing a new air conditioner make sure to get estimates from multiple contractors and select one who not only offers competitive prices and has experience with your specific model of air conditioner - but one that is dependable and is available 24/7 for emergency AC repairs.

Tips on choosing a reliable contractor for AC Installation services

When replacing your air conditioner, it is important to make sure that you hire a reliable contractor for the installation services.

This is because a bad installation job can cause unnecessary problems down the line and may even void any manufacturer’s warranties.

When selecting a contractor, look for one who is certified by the local government, has received positive customer reviews, and offers competitive prices.

Additionally, ask potential contractors about their experience installing your specific model of air conditioner and request any references they may have.

Finally, make sure to get all estimates in writing before making a decision so that you know exactly what kind of service to expect from each contractor.

Contact Dutch for schedule your AC repair and installation services - 573-315-3744

Recap: Repair or Replace Air Conditioner

Making an informed decision about whether to repair or replace your air conditioner can be a difficult task, but it's important that you weigh all the factors before making your choice. In general, repairing your existing unit can save you money in the short term while replacing it may be more cost-effective in the long run.

If your current AC is still relatively new and has just started showing signs of wear, it's likely worth repairing rather than replacing.

On the other hand, if you have an older system that is showing signs of major issues like decreased performance or breakdowns, then replacement may be the best option for you.

It's also important to consider factors like energy efficiency when selecting a new unit—the higher the efficiency rating, the less money you'll spend on energy bills over time.

Finally, make sure to consult with a reputable contractor who has experience with your specific model of air conditioner so that you can get an accurate estimate for installation costs and guarantee a good job.

Contact Dutch for schedule your AC repair and installation services - 573-315-3744

Resources -

Back to News & Media
Award-Winning Service

We’re proud to have been a 2017 recipient of the BBB Torch Award as well as a winner of the “People’s Choice Award”.

Flat Rate Pricing

We charge by the job not by the hour, so you’ll always know what to expect before any work begins.

Licensed & Background Checked

We charge by the job not by the hour, so you’ll always know what to expect before any work begins.

Turn to the experts

View Product Line

What They Say About Us

Client Testimonials

A Long Legacy of Excellence

Celebrating 60 years of award-winning 
service across our different service lines